Quoting markieness, reply 10
Quoting Mogmoogle, reply 6
Age of Wonders 1,2 (crappy)
Total War (Shogun, Medieval 1) (Hated all of them)
Dragon Age Origins (This game is also a peice of crap)
Daggerfall (Sucked)
Is he allowed to say that? or can we stone him to death now?
I know everyones a fan boy of something, but the I can explain it all.
Age of wonders 1, and 2 (They are just run of the mill RTS games, which is why I said (crappy) you can only enjoy so many RTS games that are exactly the same except with different units.)
Total War, (I really hated the way combat was controlled, and the game took forever, but had no enjoyable part about it, unlike say UFO : Enemy Unknown) it was like playing a board game with yourself, and much like doing anything with yourself just as fun.
Dragon age origins, Where do I being, much like people who actually liked the movie "V for Vendetta" theres a thousand things I can say bad about this game, but I'll limit it to the 3 most Irritating, 1.) The graphics looked like quake 2, if that actually by that I am being nice, because It remind's me of playing Quake 1, its horrible I couldn't bring myself to look at it. 2.) after I say that people are like its all about character development, how so the characters are lame and the acting is terrible, its melodramatic enough for maybe pre-teens to like, but I just couldn't get into it, it was like listening to sum 41, or one of the many other pop-punk emo crap out there, and the characters talked way to much for whatever scene they were in, they stop and talk more then they do in final fantasy, about nothing. 3.) The UI also looked like horrible pixellated crap I could hardly tell half the time when my life was going up and down. I'm serious Dungeon Siege was better.
Daggerfall (another giant sandbox game that had about as much fun as fallout 3, I walk around and kill a few people, steal some crap, and then I wander the world bored until I finally stumble around to getting to the end, its almost as bad as sacred 2's storyline "Once upon a time there was a substance known as T-Energy...... GO!" its annoying, look at fallout 3, Go find your daddy, and pretend you just didn't come out of the world of Ember... GO!" This is what we have come to these days with video games, "Ok lets make Doom 4, but this time, instead of these 9 weapons with alt fire, will remove 2 of them swap them with something else, leave it. As for the story "Sometime after the events of Doom 3.... Go!!!", Its absolutely retarded. Now I don't exactly blame those of you who are younger, and have only had access to crap games in the last 15 years so when they come out with games like Ninja Blade, or Halo, you get all into it like It actually has some quality, But you have to understand, if you've been playing since the days of pong, all the genre's really are the same, First person shooter's have changed like what 4 times in the last 25 years, new guns, vehicle, totally destructible environments, all wrapped in a new graphics candy shell, followed by a storyline that can be called just that, a "line" because it can be summed up in a sentence, "Its WWII for the 37th time, this time Hitler is trying to kill people again and you have to stop him.... Go!" after which 7 mind numbing hours later, and 18 levels of killing various Nazi's and stopping Hitler, your on to your next game, and what is it something new? why yes it is just look at Game spot "Absolutely amazing, A creative spin. and what are they praising... "Hitlers back,.. Again.. This time in an RTS, 18 more levels of fun GO!" I just can't understand why there are so many games that come out that suck so bad, Theres no fun at all theres no challenge.
Daggerfall: The Elder Scrolls 2- It sucks for the same reason.
Well if you guys like these games you'll love star trek online go play that haha, And I'm not trying to rip you guys up or anything you have a right to like what you want, I just find a lot of games over-rated, like Oblivion that was worse then Dragon Age.. All I am saying is that, I've played a lot of games in the last 25 year's and its sad because there were more games released between 1990 - 2000 that I really liked and still play on and off that were good, then anything released in the last 10, but late 2010, and 2011 might be good years
I did play Homeworld 1 and 2, however I did't like that I just drop shipped my units in and there wasn't enough base building for me.
Ya I'm pretty sure no one will mention anything I have not played so I guess I'm just SOL till one of the games I've been tracking comes out in the next few months'
Thanks for Trying
Lol the next thing you're going to be saying is that KotOR was just like every other Star Wars game and had no redeeming features. 
It basically seems more like you're afraid of personal choice. Since you apparently hate any game that says "open world environment" on the box. I don't know, I like being dropped into a giant world where I can basically do whatever I want. Don't get me wrong... I love tons of games that I played when I was a kid. Remember Megamania for the Atari 2600? No? Well, it was AMAZING. Hell, I still have a working 2600 and still play all sorts of games on it.
Anywho, back on topic, I'd suggest Bioshock (I think this was on PC?), Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic, and.... World of Goo. World of Goo is amazing... 