*peeks head in* Are we done with the drama yet? No? Okay. *walks out and closes door slowly behind him*
You mean have we all been transformed into uncritical fanbois?
No, no we have not, and we won't.
Frogboy's post really doesn't address all the issues here. As Bellack, myself, and others have said, the problems with Elemental go well beyond those of mere compatibility. It would be more reassuring if Frogboy admitted this as well, that really the level of polish and gameplay development is not at the level of a game ready to be released. However, the game does still have plenty of potential, and hopefully that potential will be realized.
If criticism, even blunt criticism, is stated in a constructive and respectful manner, it should be accepted. If it still makes you angry, then the problem doesn't lie with the person being critical.