I can't believe this thread exists. First of all, connection problems probably wouldn't be any better as the game would likely still use P2P. Also, controls would be terrible. As a previous post said, how would you deal with panning across the map, selecting skills to learn, or buying items/citadel upgrades? Not to mention casting spells or even just attacking/moving. Sure, it could work like other RTS games where there's a cursor in the center of the screen, but the game is too fast-paced for that to work effectively.
Not to mention that, as another poster said, Xbox 360 users are, on average, much less mature than PC gamers (mostly due to the large amount of teenagers). As bad as playing with random users online is on the PC, it would be a lot worse on the Xbox.
The only real reason most people are saying this is because the game didn't launch well, and the game was released on the PC. Trust me, if Demigod was released for the Xbox 360, most of you wouldn't like it, and it definitely would've gotten worse reviews. I am 100% sure Stardock will have all of the major issues ironed out within the next month, if not sooner.