JimKnopf

JimKnopf

Joined Member # 2421792
0 Posts 16 Replies 78 Reputation

In an earlier game an enemy Hero returned to being hireable again after I killed his sovereign. But in a more current game in a comparable situation the hero vanished like all the enemy troops and cities. So it seems to me this has been changed. As far as I am concerned I liked the old behaviour more.

26 Replies 82,594 Views

Many people wrote a lot of true things about MOM in this thread. But I think there are two things I like most about MOM: 1) It is always full of good and bad surprises and twists of fate that shock you or make you cheer. As an example here a short excerpt from a fictious game playing as a life mage. Positive/negative twists of are marked with +/- + I start alone on a decent land mass with two good independent cities I´m able

130 Replies 68,328 Views

[quote quoting="post"] One thing that is rather annoying in Elemental, is the use of squares and not Hexes. [/quote] Actually I think it is just a matter of taste. As an example: I prefer squares over hexes.

31 Replies 23,996 Views

FFH2 was a very well done mod for Civ IV. After I had got it I never touched vanilla Civ 4 again. Unfortunately I disliked many of the basic Civ 4 gameplay decisions. So FFH2 was much more fun than the original game but after some time it too got boring to me. Nevertheless I think the creators of FFH2 are very talented people and I would like them doing some mod work for Elemental.

196 Replies 677,778 Views

[quote who="shadowtongue" reply="34" id="2782278"] Quoting JimKnopf, reply 33 Quoting KzintiPatriarch, reply 32 Quoting JimKnopf, reply 29This is getting ridiculous ! Civ IV I bought from the bargain bin and it was even worse. You even could not raze cities that did not fit in your scheme. In one of the game setup options is the ability to raze cities or not. Apparently you didnt spend much time with Civ IV. I was not able to

47 Replies 115,247 Views

[quote who="KzintiPatriarch" reply="32" id="2782241"] Quoting JimKnopf, reply 29This is getting ridiculous ! Civ IV I bought from the bargain bin and it was even worse. You even could not raze cities that did not fit in your scheme. In one of the game setup options is the ability to raze cities or not. Apparently you didnt spend much time with Civ IV. [/quote] I was not able to find it. Actually I had to use a Python script a nice guy w

47 Replies 115,247 Views

This is getting ridiculous ! If you think you´ll like Civ 5 more than Elemental in its current state then buy it. But please spare me from this "I am sorry Stardock!" nonsense. If you think you need to apologize because you did not buy a certain Stardock game you should explain in the first place why you are thinking you are obliged to buy this game. Regarding Civ 5. I would never buy a Civ game before having read the reviews a

47 Replies 115,247 Views

This is getting ridiculous ! If you think you´ll like Civ 5 more than Elemental in its current state then buy it. But please spare me from this "I am sorry Stardock!" nonsense. If you think you need to apologize because you did not buy a certain Stardock game you should explain in the first place why you are thinking you are obliged to buy this game. Regarding Civ 5. I would never buy a Civ game before having read the reviews and checked the game play. Civ I and

47 Replies 115,247 Views

[quote who="GaelicVigil" reply="109" id="2772014"] Edit: By the way, why are you still posting here anyway? the OP clearly stated that "if you Don't want to see this, please keep your replies in the other thread. Thank you."[/quote] Maybe because there is no sense in playing fair if the other side does not so as well. In post #103 you are claiming the OP is right because the majority of posts in this thread support him. https://forums.elementa

420 Replies 1,127,798 Views

[quote who="GaelicVigil" reply="104" id="2771999"] Disagree all you want, but until you can cite a source that claims that size is not a requirement for being epic, your personal definition means nothing.[/quote] It means a lot, Because it is not about whose definition of epic is right and whose is wrong. It is about what the majority of people regard as Epic. And it seems to me that the majority is more interested in good gameplay than in as much soldiers as possi

420 Replies 1,127,798 Views

[quote who="GaelicVigil" reply="103" id="2771997"] He's speaking for the majority, which has been proven by the number of people in favor on this thread.[/quote] LOL He essentially wrote: Post in this thread here if you like my idea or post in the other thread ( https://forums.elementalgame.com/396093 ) if you don´t. And now you are claiming that he is right because in this thread is more s

420 Replies 1,127,798 Views

[quote]Yes, and making battles larger will make it more epic. Epic would be a perfectly fine word to use for a really big star, it would be perfectly fine to use for anything that has "more" or is "bigger" than the rest.[/quote] So an army of 100,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 dragons annihilating 100,000,000 zombies is more epic to you than a lonely heavily wounded hero defeating an evil necromancer before he is able to summon enough undead to destroy the world ?

420 Replies 1,127,798 Views

My opinion regarding this thread here and this one: https://forums.elementalgame.com/396516 . At the moment I strongly oppose raising the number of combatants per battle only because some people think that would make battles more epic. I strongly believe that currently there are more urgent tasks to do for SD. And it seems to me they are on a good way. I´m really looking forward to the city screen announced for 1.08. Epic, at least in

72 Replies 53,810 Views

[quote who="Bobby Hardenbrook" reply="27" id="2763779"]1.07 is officially stable as far as I am concerned. One CTD and one minor graphical glitch in 20+ hours of gameplay, thats acceptable for a game this early in the release IMHO. In fact thats the same rate of issues I've had with SC2. If 1.07 had been the initial release version I bet the early reviews would have been a lot better. Oh well, its stable now and Stardock has already showed the game plan out to ve

33 Replies 158,933 Views

I am wondering if you are talking about this forum, I am currently posting to ? Actually I think the vast majority of people who critisized SD did it in a quite constructive way. I much more often noticed threads in which criticless supporters of stardock where attacking people with legitimate (at least in my opinion) concerns about the game. (The company itself and especially Mr. Wardell is dealing with the critics in a very professional and open manner.) If you take

33 Replies 158,933 Views