IMPORTANT! Re: Requesting skins

The message boards again seem to be steadily filling up with requests for the creation of particular skins. There are certain important rules to consider before making a request.

1. No movie, TV show, band, video game or brand name skin requests.

The copyright issues involved in creating such a skin are simply too big for any legitimate skinner to get involved. If a skin uses the trademarks/copyrights held by another party, then the author is opening themselves up to the possibility of a costly legal battle.

While it's true that certain skins do exist in these categories, they tend to fall into two distinct groups. Those which have been created as a result of a commission from the owner of the copyright, and those which have been created by 'new' skinners who don't know or understand the potential legal repercussions of their actions.

2. Be polite.

Never demand a skin. It isn't your right to have a particular skin made for you, and you're not going to get any help through bad manners. Simply state what you'd like to see, and don't get upset if you don't get any takers.

Some people seem to think that by buying a commercial skinning/customization application (eg. WindowBlinds, DesktopX, IconPackager), they are also buying the right to have skins of their own design. This is like complaining to a car dealer when they refuse to supply you with unlimited fuel and CDs to play on the stereo.

3. Be specific.

Don't just ask for a 'blue skin' or 'a skin with nice buttons'. There are plenty of those around if you only look.

For a skinner to get enthusiastic about creating a skin, they need to have a relatively clear picture in their mind of what they want to finished result to look like. If you can 'sell' the idea of a particular skin, you're far more likely to generate interest for your idea.

4. Skinning takes time.

If someone said they'd look into creating a skin for you on Monday, don't pester them on Tuesday to ask where it is. A good skin takes days, weeks, or sometimes months to create. Be patient and if you're lucky you'll eventually get what you wanted.

5. D.I.Y.

If you can't find anyone to create your dream skin for you, why no do it yourself? We all started somewhere, and if you have a good enough idea you're half-way there already. Just sit down with whatever tools you can get your hands on and give it a try.

Skinners are far more likely to give you advice on the mechanics of skin creation than they are to create an entire skin for you.

Who knows, one day you could be the one giving out the advice.
38,409 views 101 replies
Reply #1 Top
thank you for this post grayhaze, i was starting to get bogged down...
Reply #2 Top
I agree, well said



Powered by SkinBrowser!
Reply #3 Top
Sounds good.

Now, I need you to make a Nickleback skin with nice buttons by tommorow, and I cant do it myself because I'm lazy. >

Just kidding.
Reply #5 Top
Thank you Grayhaze...

Methinks this should be sticky...
Reply #6 Top
Methinks it IS sticky now.....
Reply #7 Top
now if more posters would read the sticky threads...
Reply #8 Top
I want a blue skin, one with nice buttons...

Oh, someone just uploaded one

Well said though. The number of these request threads is getting tiresome Nice if people would think before posting (or read this thread )
Reply #9 Top
I want a blue skin, one with nice buttons...Oh, someone just uploaded one


Funny...I am porting one right now.
Reply #10 Top
I want a grey one [naturally]...oh yes.....thanks, treetog...
Reply #11 Top
i want a skin that does the dishes. washes my car and cooks a pizza while i sit in the hot tub ...ohh and has glassy blue buttons ....
Reply #12 Top

HG_E....

I've almost got one of those.....

 

 

OK...

 

Well it's got the glassy blue buttons......

Reply #13 Top
Too bad most requesters probably won't bother reading any thread, much less this one, before they post.



Powered by SkinBrowser!
Reply #14 Top
that does the dishes. washes my car and cooks a pizza while i sit in the hot tub ...ohh and has glassy blue buttons


I've almost got one of those..... OK... Well it's got the glassy blue buttons......



You might not have your own 'buttons' if that post leaks out ...
Mine's got red hair as well ....
Reply #18 Top
I want a skin that will never get wrinkles or spots.
Reply #19 Top
HG_E....I've almost got one of those..... OK... Well it's got the glassy blue buttons......


he makes the post i get the smack...*i gotta stop letin her read over my shoulder *..
Reply #20 Top
good rules to follow
Reply #21 Top
Guess I'll never get that Farscape skin now! Just kidding! Wouldn't want anyone getting sued by Hensen! And btw some of us do try to read through th threads to get answers first,always try to learn from mistakes/solutions of others rather than stick foot in mouth [not that I've ever done that ,of course]
Reply #22 Top
i have become accustomed to the flavor of foot ...
Reply #23 Top
A question (that may already been answered)...

Relating to copyrighted this and that, why can't a skin still be made even though it's not for profit? I understand the potential lawsuits, but wouldn't the skins/icons be a way of advertising for the company? Why would they object?
Reply #24 Top
Relating to copyrighted this and that, why can't a skin still be made even though it's not for profit? I understand the potential lawsuits, but wouldn't the skins/icons be a way of advertising for the company? Why would they object?


Without wanting to get into another long discussion on the issue, here's the quick answer. When a company holds the copyright to a piece of work, they usually like to maintain full control over how and where that work is used.

Whether a copyright infringment is carried out for profit or otherwise is irrelevant, as copyright law makes no concessions for non-profit use.

The idea that derivative works serve as advertising for the original owner of the copyright is also a rather naive concept, as once the material is out of their hands they have absolutely no control over how it, or they, are represented by those derivative works.

To say that a sloppy cut-and-paste skin from copyrighted images and logos could serve as positive advertising is just ludicrous. These poor rip-offs only serve to dilute and corrupt the image of the original product.

If the owner wants advertising, they'll pay for it to be done well and to their own specifications. That way they maintain control of their product and avoid tainting its image through unauthorized poor workmanship.
[Message Edited]
Reply #25 Top
I prefer "to the point" rather than a long discussion myself. One/two more questions, fan art. Does "fan art" fit into this as well? Couldn't one say his/her skin is a fan art?

What about parody? (Taking note that booble.com is claiming its site is a parody of google.com, thus cannot be sued for copy infrigment etc. Heard on TechTV.)