I've discovered what happens - it changes to an unbuilt death shard, and stays an unbuilt death shard until you reload, when it becomes a life shard. But Kingdom champions (including sov if a Kingdom) can't appear to upgrade Death Magic on levelup (6 or 7 levels of testing, so not conclusive, but likely) but if you hire a Death Magic hero, that gets Death Magic 2 from levelups or starts with at least Death Magic 2, you can do it. (So obviously you need to have picked Betrayers.)