Draginol Draginol

Regular lighting vs. advanced lighting

Regular lighting vs. advanced lighting

image image

It’s interesting to see a case where one isn’t definitely better than the other. Regular lighting looks pretty good I think. It’s sharper. Advanced lighting looks good too. It’s softer. I wonder if this should be renamed to Soft Lighting or something because it implies that one is more “advanced” than the other.

75,679 views 34 replies
Reply #26 Top

Quoting Martok, reply 14
Honestly, I can't tell the difference.  It all looks the same to me. 

Out of curiosity, which lighting is easier on one's PC hardware (if either)?
End of Martok's quote

Same opinion and question from me!

 

Seriously, all those video and audio options are like "WTF!" for me. It's just über-geeking pushed too far. I couldn't even guess what means "anti-aliasing" if my life was at stake with it.

So don't forget to include a few lines about them in the manual (you can call the chapter "Computer games 101" if you want! :blush: )

Reply #27 Top

regular is better to me

on advanced one : at the right of heads are too much of light ...too shiny - not good for eyes -_-

PS: I love cloudy! ^_^'

...sorry for my English...

Reply #28 Top

Well I can't tell which 1 is which, but personally I like the 1 on the left better. The 1 on the right looks as though it has too much gamma or contrast turned up as compared to the 1 on the left, and the background textures are not as defined.

Reply #29 Top

Well, for those that can tell the difference (most) ... the choice seems clear.

Reply #30 Top

I have a request, could you please put in better explanations as to what each option is when we mouse over them. Because some are just not too clear (actully most are not.)

Reply #31 Top

To me the trees/bushes look better on the right but the people look better on the left. Now all in all I don't like the animation in the game but I think if I can combine the two (soft for the plants and sharp for the People/monsters/buildings) then maybe it won't have that anime look which I don't care for.  But it is not bad enough to annoy me and the gameplay as well as the cloth map is good.

Reply #32 Top

Having poor eyesight in real life, and after having looked at these two images, I must concur that I find the "regular" lighting to be more to my liking. The reason is simple, the contrast is much better with the "regular" light when compared to to the "advanced/soft" light. This is something I find very important in games, for obvious reasons, as it's one of the things which define whetever or not I have to spend several minutes squinting my eyes to make out certain things, or whetever I can just take a look at it and then move on. Blurriness and washed-out colors makes me sad in pants. D:

Reply #33 Top

The slider for the advanced lighting does not work here. Changes nothing whatever I set it to, the level of softness is always the same. And yes I turned Stylized Lighting on. ;)

Reply #34 Top

Quoting Xiskio, reply 33
The slider for the advanced lighting does not work here. Changes nothing whatever I set it to, the level of softness is always the same. And yes I turned Stylized Lighting on.
End of Xiskio's quote

YES same here, i made a topic (with comparison screens) but noone bothered to answer :(
https://forums.elementalgame.com/393909