Book Review: The Bell Jar

Captivating and confusing from the beginning...

Book Review: The Bell Jar

Captivating and confusing from the beginning, "The Bell Jar," allows one to slip from scene to scene, often times not in any sort of order, in Esther Greenwood's abstract and dark life. As she moves from asylum to asylum doo people come and go in her life. She has many emotions, which the author portrays clearly, and rides a spiraling path downward.

"I had missed a perfectly good chance. The river water passed me by like an untouched drink. I suspected that if my mother and brother had not been there I would have made no move to jump." *

Esther is a confused young woman, confused as many of us may be at times. But it's almost as if her confusing and frustration is taking to a deeper level, and almost nuetral ground. She becomes depressed and unable to read or write. She sees therapists and visits numerous mental institues and physiatrists.

The author, Sylvia Plath, who published this novel in 1971, depicts the emotions and feelings of her characters well through the use of many adjectives; ones that leave the reader feeling connected. Plath is detailed and although no major plot is established, the reader somehow grasps the complexion of Esther's character. Albeit, at times it may be difficult to follow the general changes of the story.

Just as a bell jar surrounds a porcelien doll, a type of Bell Jar hangs over Esther's fragile being like something inescapable.

There's a capturing, uncommon enigma that draws one into Esther's life, but leaves something to be desired with a considerably inconclusive ending.

~Sarah

*excerpt from "The Bell Jar"
4,659 views 4 replies
Reply #1 Top
Hoping for a comment from Anne or MadPoet, or anyone for that matter!

~Sarah
note:no idea how "doo" got in there... lol
Reply #2 Top
Have you ever read Sylvia Plath's unabridged diary? It's a good read. I remember reading the Bell Jar and thinking that I would like Plath more as an author than a poet. It's also what got me interested in Anne Sexton and Erica Jong (a Sylvia Plath admirer who has written poetry dedicated both to Plath.)
Reply #3 Top

Hoping for a comment from Anne or MadPoet, or anyone for that matter!


Just as a bell jar surrounds a porcelien doll, a type of Bell Jar hangs over Esther's fragile being like something inescapable.


BigDreamer~did somebody mention my name? . I like much of the writing here. Especially your quote from above. The trouble with The Bell Jar is that Sylvia never intended it to become great literature, and somehow (due to the huge legend of the tragic author perhaps?) the novel has ended up becoming a minor classic, and is studied far and wide now in so many high schools and universities, etc.


It is quite autobiographical. Nearly everything she describes in the book she actually experienced herself. But she distorted truth for literary effect, and changed all the names to protect the innocent and guilty big time. I think the book is all the more touching when you realize Sylvia basically wanted to write something quite sensational that would bring in a ton of money, and then the book got a very cold welcome after it was published in England (where it was first published in 1963~she used the pseudonym Victoria Lucas). The bestseller she hoped to write was not meant to be. Until after her tragic death at the age of 31. Then after Ariel was published a bit later on, and became as much of a bestseller as a book of poetry can possibly achieve~somebody revealed that Victoria Lucas was indeed Sylvia Plath! So suddenly everybody wanted to read the nearly forgotten novel big time.


When the United States heard about the sudden success of The Bell Jar in England~the book was finally published in America (around 1971?), and would soon become a bestseller here. And poor Sylvia never knew a thing about it. All her dreams of becoming a famous poet and novelist would come true~but quite posthumously. The poor woman didn't even have her own telephone in that cold and damp flat in England where she ended her life much too soon. The whole Sylvia Plath story is sad and remarkable in ways we will never fully understand. She was clearly a very beautiful and awesome genius. But was so afraid of other people that she always felt the need to put on some kind of "mask" when she had to be around other folks.


Yet most of her poetry (and even The Bell Jar) is about becoming real and genuine, and letting go of all our artificial selves. She still breaks my heart. No other poet has moved me as much as she has. I think the poor girl was literally panic stricken most of her life. But she slowly mastered her craft, somehow put on a brave face, stepped out into the big bad world, and literally became the second most famous American poet~second only to Emily Dickinson! Now how did she do all that, huh? Especially given her fragile mental state so much of the time. She was a beautiful enigma. One that will go on haunting us forever:


"To the person in the bell jar, blank and stopped as a dead baby~the world itself is the bad dream."


~Sylvia Plath


P.S. You are a very fine writer. I like much of what you have done here. I must say it really made my day to discover a JU blogger had actually written something about The Bell Jar! Very nicely done. Now if only Anne will turn up? But she's been rather scarce lately, huh? She was going to write something about Sylvia Plath also~but I don't think that has happened yet. Keep on blogging big time!


~MadPoet

Reply #4 Top
Wow, thanks for the great comment. I appreciate it "big time" I love how you always say that... whenever I hear it, I think of you. lol

Now if only Anne will turn up? But she's been rather scarce lately, huh? She was going to write something about Sylvia Plath also~but I don't think that has happened yet. Keep on blogging big time!


I had actually never heard of the Bell Jar until Anne raved about it all the time. I think Anne's writing is great (that is when she does write) and I admire her as a person, so I figured I'd give it a try.

Thanks again!

~Sarah