The current ESC key behavior is confusing and inconsistent:
- Hitting ESC while a popup is open appears to do nothing until the popup closes. Then the Options menu pops up, which is confusing.
- Exception: In some cases, ESC immediately closes the popup and opens the Options menu, which is inconsistent. Ex: the "Kingdom Report" popup.
The following would be more intuitive:
- If any "popup" is open, then ESC closes it (but doesn't open Options. Where "popup" is:
* Any Menu (e.g. Options menu, City build menu, Kingdom report, NPC details)
* Any Dialogue box (e.g. enter name of city to build, recruit NPC)
* Any Book (e.g. book that covers screen at start of game).
* Anything that pops up on the screen that isn't the main map.
- If no "popup" is open, then ESC opens the Options menu.
In general, this falls under the category of streamlining the interface. There is a lot of "move mouse, then click X/Done/Back to Game", when all of these fall under the traditional function of ESC.